
Katelynn Sobus / Cats.com
Do you feel like you’re playing with your cat constantly but they’re still hyperactive and always getting into trouble? It can be difficult to keep up with super active cats, but one piece of the puzzle is providing mental enrichment, rather than only physical exercise.
Another important step is encouraging independent play so that your cat has something to do while you’re working from home or cleaning the house, and they aren’t constantly nagging for more playtime.
In this article, I review eight of the top interactive cat toys on the market to see which ones work best for every unique cat purr-sonality, whether they like hunting lizards, solving puzzles, or chasing balls around a track.
At a Glance: Best Interactive Cat Toys for Bored Cats
Want a quick look at the products reviewed in this article? In the comparison table below, we’ve highlighted some of the most important features of each product. You’ll find more detailed information about each product later in the article.
PawsPik Interactive Fast Rolling Play Mat Ball Cat Toy
- With various settings and an optional play mat, cats can get a different experience each time
- Realistic bird sounds and LED lights keep cats engaged and coming back for more
- A touch of a paw turns it back on, so that you don’t have to get up every time your cat is ready to play
Catit Senses 2.0 Super Circuit Cat Toy
- Give your cat a new experience each play session, with over 100 set-ups to choose from
- A variety of shapes and elevations keep play exciting, helping the ball move less predictably through the track
- Great for bonding between cats and children
Cat Dancer 101 Cat Dancer Interactive Cat Toy
- Unpredictable, springy movements keep cats engaged
- Cats love to chase the rolls of paper at the end–and this design is eco-friendly!
- Lightweight and affordable
TRIXIE Brain Mover Activity Strategy Game
- This board contains several mini-puzzles for your cat to figure out, keeping them interested for longer
- Helps cats to eat slowly, rather than scarfing down meals
- Dishwasher safe
PetSafe SlimCat Interactive Cat Feeder
- Easy to figure out, even for cats who struggle with other puzzle toys
- Encourages movement and play, helping cats stay active and lose weight
- Adjustable holes allow you to change the difficulty level and account for various kibble sizes
Catstages Tower of Tracks
- Features three stacked tracks with two balls each
- Encourages group play between cats
- Inspires cats to engage in natural hunting behaviors such as stalking and pouncing
PawsPik Feather Tail Rechargeable Spinner Chasers
- Four randomized motion patterns and three speed settings give your cat a new experience every time they play
- Automatically goes into standby mode, turning back on with the touch of a paw
- Works on various floor types, including carpet
Pet Fit For Life Dual Rod Wand Cat Toy
- Comes with a foam handle that’s comfortable to hold, as well as a long pole so that you don’t have to bend while playing
- With four attachments included and more sold separately, playtime is endless and ever-changing
- The flexible wand causes unpredictable movements, keeping cats engaged with minimal effort from cat parents
Why Trust Cats.com
I’m a lifelong cat owner with seven senior cats of my own. Over the years, I’ve purchased well over a hundred cat toys–from cheap multi-packs containing toys that were destroyed in days to quality products that have held up for years.
While choosing toys for this article, the Cats.com team considered our own favorites, spoke with other cat parents to learn what their cats enjoy, and read hundreds of reviews for the most popular cat toys in the market. Then, I purchased and tested them with my own cats to see what they thought! Below are my honest reviews.
Top 8 Interactive Cat Toys Tested and Reviewed
We considered several factors while choosing toys for this article. While the PawsPik interactive play mat is our top choice for most cats, we’ve aimed to provide options for all kinds of purr-sonalities. That’s why we’ve broken our selections into categories, to offer you the best puzzle toy, the best track toy, and more.
How to Choose the Best Interactive Cat Toys
There are so many interactive cat toys out there that it can be difficult to tell the good from the bad. Here are some things to think about before buying:
Mental Enrichment
The best interactive cat toys mimic your cat’s favorite prey or provide a challenge (usually involving food) to keep their minds occupied. These types of toys provide mental enrichment, which is vital for entertaining a bored cat.
Hands-On vs Independent Play
Before buying your next interactive cat toy, consider how hands-on you want to be. While cats benefit from daily play with their owners, busy cat parents can benefit from having both hands-on and low-effort cat toys in the home.
Some cat toys require you to pay attention in order to provide an enriching experience for your cat, while with others you only have to flip a switch and watch your cat go wild! If you have more of one category than the other, consider switching things up for your next purchase.
Difficulty
All kinds of things can add to the difficulty level of your cat’s toys, from the complexity of a puzzle toy to how fast an electronic toy glides across the floor. Difficulty isn’t a bad thing, but it’s important to choose the right difficulty level for your cat.
For instance, intelligent cats need more complex puzzles to keep them engaged. But if your cat’s first puzzle toy is too challenging, they may get frustrated and give up altogether.
Cats with health problems may need slow-moving toys or toys that stay in one central location, while super active cats will have fun with faster ‘prey.’
It’s all about knowing your unique cat, their abilities, and their preferences.
Variation
Look for cat toys that can be played with in a variety of ways. While every cat is different, many of them will get bored if given the same puzzle again and again. It also won’t provide the mental challenge that it did in the beginning, and your cat will end up bored again pretty quickly.
Another way to add variation to your cat’s playtime is to rotate toys regularly. Bring out the wand toy for one play session, then set up an electronic toy for them while you’re busy with chores later in the day. If you notice your cat becoming bored with a particular toy, putting it away for a while can renew their interest next time you bring it out.
Ease of Cleaning
Cleanup is easy to overlook until you’re scrubbing every nook and cranny of a puzzle feeder. If the toy holds food at all, I recommend thinking about how easy it will be to clean and if you want to keep up with that maintenance after each use.
Another option is to look for toys that are dishwasher safe so that you don’t have to scrub them yourself.
I have two very spoiled 2-year old female kitties. I’m finding they get very bored with something we play within a short period of time. I have every one of the toys you recommend above except for the Hexbug Robotic Cat Toy. We have scratch posts throughout the house, and a huge tower to climb, which one uses to scratch and the other uses to sleep up high. The feeder ball is only good for a little bit of time by one of them. We played Da Bird every day for a long time when they were both little, and now they sit there and say ho hum. I can bring out one of several da birds and maybe once in a while they’ll play. I have the cat dancer which didn’t keep interest very long and when I try to bring it back out, they look at it and say ho hum to that. I have the Tower and Circuit toy, but neither are played with for more than a few seconds. We have a large tunnel and I also build a tunnel on my bed every morning with pillows. Once in a while I can hide the da bird in one of the openings and they’ll pounce on the pillows, but it doesn’t last long. I’ve had several Pouncing Paws which they both played with for longer periods of time, but after they didn’t touch it for a while, I hid it in the closet. I’ll bring it out after a long period of absence, but it doesn’t have the appeal it once did, so back in the closet it goes. One of my cats loves for me to shoot rubber bands in the air and she will catch them. The other one hears the word rubber band and high tails it out of the room. We used to play with the bouncy ball, but they don’t chase it anymore either. I also used to take all the cat balls I own (I have a LOT) and open a paper bag at the other end of the room. Then I would roll them toward the bag. But that seems too boring, too. The latest kick they seem to be on is string. I have a long piece of regular string and a long piece of sisal. I walk around dragging the string behind me, and both of them follow me and try to grab one or the other. If I can catch an end under a box or something, it’s way more fun to try to catch the end before it disappears under the box. But I’m running out of ideas. They aren’t crazy about mice, only one likes catnip, so when they come to me in the evening and want to play, I ask them what, but get no answer. Birdie gets an eyes down, and string gets a little murr. I definitely get more exercise with the string than they do. I’ve also hidden treats at various places throughout the great room, but I don’t want to keep giving them so many treats. Any other recommendations would be much appreciated! Thanks, I really enjoy your information!
Hi Karen, thanks for the message! Really, it sounds like you’re doing everything right! Cats will get tired of toys that they’ve been playing with for a long time, and their tastes will change over time. Keep experimenting and engaging with them, and you’ll be just fine. You can also try helping them get some enrichment from a catio or outdoor exploration!
One of our two cats loves the doorway dangler, which reels a lightweight target up and down unpredictably. She even plays with it when it’s not on. The other plays with it in shorter bursts.
Both cats adore chasing a laser pointer. If your cats also love that, there is at least one automatic laser pointer toy that is truly random motion. We don’t have a good place for that, so we stick to the little cheap lasers.