
Katelynn Sobus / Cats.com
Play is essential for every cat, whether you have a kitten who goes through toys like a teething puppy or a senior who can’t run and jump like they used to. It’s important not just for physical exercise, but to keep their minds sharp and engaged. Of course, the key is finding the right toy for your individual cat.
I know that every cat is different, which is why I’ve tested a wide selection of toys, ranging from catnip stuffies to electronic motion toys. For this article, I chose 16 toys to test and came away with 14 recommendations. Let’s hop into my honest reviews.
At a Glance: Best Cat Toys to Buy
Want a quick look at the products reviewed in this article? In the comparison table below, we’ve highlighted some of the most important features of each product. You’ll find more detailed information about each product later in the article.
Potaroma 3 in 1 Automatic Interactive Butterfly Cat Toy
- Features a fluttering butterfly teaser, a pop-out feather teaser, and two balls on a track
- Once on, the toy can remain in standby mode for up to 4 hours, activating with the touch of a paw
- An excellent choice for supervised play sessions
Cat Dancer 101 Interactive Cat Toy
- Flexible wire moves unpredictably, encouraging cats to play
- Eco-friendly and budget-friendly
- A great choice for hands-on play sessions
Cat Dancer Cat Charmer Interactive Cat Toy
- Lightweight and flexible
- Long ribbon soars through the air with minimal effort
- Unpredictable movements keep cats engaged
Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy
- Filled with high-quality, organic catnip with no stuffing or small pieces
- Made entirely in the USA
- An excellent choice for independent playAn excellent choice for independent play
Potaroma Chew Ropes Cat Toy
- Contains silvervine and catnip to keep cats engaged
- An excellent choice for cats who like to chew or kick their toys
- Great for independent or hands-on play sessions
Coastal Pet Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy
- 2-in-1 cat scratcher and track toy
- Large size and non-slip bottom encourage cats of all sizes to scratch and play
- Horizontal scratcher can help redirect cats who scratch carpets, rugs, or tops of furniture
Quirky Kitty Mice Cream Hide-A-Toy Cat Toy
- Hide-a-toy design provides mental enrichment by giving your cat a small puzzle to solve
- Contains high-quality North American catnip
- Can be filled with treats or extra catnip for added fun
Frisco Axolotl Jumbo Plush Kicker Cat Toy with Silvervine & Catnip
- 16” long kicker toy is designed with large cats in mind
- Contains silvervine and catnip to encourage play
- Crinkly material keeps cats engaged in playtime
Catit Senses 2.0 Super Circuit Cat Toy
- Contains 12 tracks that can be arranged into over 100 different configurations
- Compatible with tracks from other Catit Senses 2.0 toys
- A great choice for independent or hands-on play
PetSafe SlimCat Interactive Cat Feeder
- A simple, engaging puzzle toy that makes mealtimes fun
- Encourages cats to eat slowly and engage in natural hunting behaviors such as batting and chasing
- Dishwasher safe
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Cat Toys
- Easy for cats to toss, carry, and bat around
- Perfect for hands-on games of fetch
- Comes in an affordable pack of 10 colorful mice
GoCat Da Bird Single Pole Cat Teaser
- Long, lightweight wand toy
- Encourages cats to run and jump with minimal effort from cat parents
- Flexible wand creates unpredictable, engaging movements
HEX BOTS Nano
- Realistic bug-like movements engage your cat’s hunting instincts
- Lightweight design is easy for cats to bat and toss around
- A great choice for supervised play sessions
Catstages Tower of Tracks Interactive Cat Toy
- Includes three tracks containing six balls total
- Encourages cats to pounce, swat, and chase
- Cats can play independently or with other cats
Top Picks Explained
Why Trust Cats.com
While choosing products for this article, our team scoured customer reviews, chatted with other cat parents, and used our experience with our own cats to make the best selections possible.
Before writing this article, I purchased and tested each product with my own cats. They’re seniors now, so not as rambunctious as kittens, but still pretty active!

Katelynn Sobus / Cats.com
I took notes on how the cats responded to the toys, my own experience holding wand toys or setting up electronic toys, and how each one held up under rough play (my boys love to chew!). I also thought about how cats of different ages or with different play styles may react to each toy, in order to recommend to each unique cat and cat parent the best products possible.
In addition to the toys below, I also tested two additional selections that didn’t make the cut: the Kitty Kaster cat wand and the PetSafe Bolt automatic laser cat toy.
The Kitty Kaster had a great design in the handle and wand, but unfortunately fell apart within one play session. I was able to tie the felt toy back onto the string, and Kitty Kaster does sell replacements—but ultimately, I didn’t feel the quality held up to the expensive price tag.
The PetSafe Bolt wouldn’t turn on unless I was pressing down on the battery cover the entire time. When I looked into the issue, I saw a couple of other reviewers mention a similar problem. While most of the lasers they sell seem to work fine, there does seem to be a design flaw in some of them where the cover just isn’t tight enough for the toy to function properly.
Top 14 Cat Toys Tested and Reviewed
Every cat is unique, with their own play style and preferences. When it comes to interactive toys, cat parents want different things as well!
Our overall top pick is the Potaroma 3-in-1 automatic interactive butterfly toy because it’s versatile and keeps cats entertained without much work for cat parents. However, this toy isn’t the best way to bond with your cat, and won’t encourage jumping or running.
That’s why we’ve broken our selections into categories, so that you can choose the best one for your needs. Whether you’re trying to schedule more exercise into your cat’s day, make meal times more enriching, or encourage independent play, we’ve got you covered!
How to Choose the Best Toys for Your Cat
There are so many different types of cat toys out there that it can be difficult to choose between them! Here are some things I think about before buying toys for my own cats:
Look at Their Existing Toys
First, take a look at your cat’s toy collection! Do they already have a lot of catnip toys, but not very many electronic ones? Do you have a few toys they can use while supervised, but not as many designed for independent play? Maybe you haven’t purchased any new puzzle toys for them in a while!
If it feels like something is missing, that’s a great place to start. It’s always nice for new toys to provide something new for your cat, even if it’s just a different texture or sound.
If you’ve just adopted your cat and they don’t have any toys, I recommend starting with the basics: a nice wand toy, a few toys designed for independent play such as stuffed catnip toys, and perhaps an electronic toy for when you can supervise but are too busy for hands-on activities.
Think About Your Cat’s Play Style
Next, think about how your cat plays already. Questions you may ask yourself include:
- While playing with a wand toy, does my cat prefer to see it soaring through the air or wriggling on the ground? Are there other toys that can mimic those movements?
- How active is my cat? Do I want to encourage or discourage strenuous activity? (Stationary electronic toys can be awesome for cats with disabilities, while wand toys are the best for getting cats up and moving.)
- How rough is my cat on their toys? Do I need to look for something extra sturdy, or will most toys hold up okay?
Trying new things is wonderful, but we also want to avoid buying something our cats won’t like, or something they’ll tear to pieces within a week!
Choosing the Best Toys
Now that you have a better idea of what kind of toy you’d like to buy, it’s time to start browsing. Look for toys that:
- Fit into your budget, but keep in mind that very cheap toys may need to be replaced more often. Sometimes, spending a few extra dollars makes all the difference.
- Are durable and will hold up over time. Bonus points if they have replaceable parts and are easy to keep clean!
- Are fun for you and your cat! Cats need daily play, so be sure to pick something that you can both enjoy playing with for the duration. In addition to your cat’s preferences, consider your own convenience. This doesn’t mean avoiding hands-on play sessions, but it might mean choosing wand toys with comfortable handles, electronic toys that have a standby mode so that your cat can reactivate them without you getting up, and other features that help you to play with your cat more consistently.
Lastly, something that’s nice to have are toys without small parts or stuffing inside. This can be difficult to find in a cat toy, and is typically more costly. Not every cat toy needs to fit these criteria, but you’ll want at least a couple that you can safely allow your cat to play with unattended.
On the other hand, toys used only under your supervision, such as wand toys, can be made more exciting to your cat with things like bells and feathers. Just inspect them before each use to make sure nothing is tearing or coming loose from the toy.