Updated Mar 31, 2023
Medically reviewed by
Our Review Process
Our reviews are based on extensive research and, when possible, hands-on testing. Each time you make a purchase through one of our independently-chosen links, we’ll receive a percentage of the proceeds. Read more about how we’re supported here.The best fresh cat food meal delivery service ships out high-quality, ultra-nourishing meals, helping you give your cat his best life while making yours a little bit easier.
Because it combines human-grade ingredient quality with cat-worthy nutrition and is one of the only services that provide customized portions, we’ve chosen Smalls as the overall best fresh cat food meal delivery service.
To help you get an idea of which fresh cat food delivery service is right for you, we’ve chosen four strong candidates and gone in-depth on each.
You’ll get all the important details on the top fresh cat food delivery companies, such as how to sign up, how easy it is to cancel your subscription, where and how the foods are made, and how diverse their meal options are.
At A Glance: Best Best Fresh Cat Food Meal Delivery Service
Want a quick look at the products reviewed in this article? In the comparison table below, we’ve highlighted some of the most important features of each product. You’ll find more detailed information about each product later in the article.
Smalls Cat Food Delivery
- Wide variety of recipes and product types
- Rich in species-appropriate nutrition for cats
- High-quality, human-grade ingredients
Raised Right Cat Food
- Recipes formulated by veterinarian, Dr. Karen Becker
- Limited ingredient whole food recipes that are low in carbs
- 100% human-grade food made in a USDA inspected facility
JustCats Fresh Cat Food
- Rich in high-quality animal protein
- High moisture content
- Easily digestible, no artificial additives
FreshPet Fresh Cat Food
- Store-bought alternative to meal delivery
- Wide variety of product choices
- Steam-cooked to preserve nutrition
Why Should You Trust Us?
Having reviewed 200 of the world’s most popular cat food brands and hundreds of recipes, we’ve spent countless hours researching both feline nutrition and the pet industry.
We’ve consulted with veterinarians and animal nutrition experts, talked to industry insiders, and tried out dozens of recipes with our own cats.
Keep reading to get the details on the best fresh cat food meal delivery services available.
Here’s What We Look For When Evaluating Cat Food Meal Delivery Services
Before we jump into the reviews, let’s talk about what we look for in a great cat food meal delivery service.
The Subscription And Ordering Process Should Be Smooth And User-friendly.
Whenever you sign up for a recurring delivery service, you put yourself at risk of creating more hassle and frustration for yourself.
Between surprise charges on your credit card, difficulty canceling your subscription, and confusing customer portals, these types of services can be a nightmare. The best fresh cat food delivery services make the process painless or even enjoyable.
We’re looking for easy navigation, plenty of options for customizing your subscription, and a history of good customer service.
The Best Fresh Cat Food Meal Delivery Service Gives Your Cat Top-Notch Nutrition
When you open up the package, the food inside should be high-quality and healthy.
As a baseline, the food should be nutritionally complete and balanced according to the guidelines set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).
And beyond meeting those baseline nutritional requirements, great cat food is rich in animal protein, with the right amount of fat and not too much plant matter. Ideally, all of that nutrition comes from top-of-the-line ingredients that are sourced from reputable suppliers and manufactured according to the highest standards.
We Looked For Brands That Offered A Good Variety Of Meal Options.
If you’re going to be relying on a cat food delivery service as your cat’s only source of food, that service should be able to provide the types of protein sources, textures, and flavors your cat likes and needs.
It doesn’t hurt if the brand offers more than just fresh food as well – what cat doesn’t love treats and food toppers?
We Also Thought About Price.
Buying a fresh cat food meal delivery isn’t cheap, but it should be affordable. We evaluated each brand’s pricing structure to see if its price aligned with the level of quality and service it delivered.
In addition to performing our own qualitative analysis of the brands reviewed here, we submitted samples for analysis at an ISO 17025 certified food testing and analysis lab.
Also Read: Why We Lab Test Cat Food and How to Interpret the Reports
We bought the products at full retail price, and the entire testing process was funded by Cats.com without direct input or influence from the companies involved.
Analytical testing in a food chemistry lab gives us the exact macronutrient and micronutrient content of each recipe. The tests also look at microbial content, yeast, mold, and heavy metals, helping you ensure that you’re only putting the best in your cat’s bowl.
To access the lab reports for each food reviewed here, click the “view lab report” link in the product review.
The Best Fresh Cat Food Meal Delivery: Our Top Recommendations
#1 Overall Best: Smalls Cat Food Delivery
ENTER "ALLABOUTCATS" TO GET 30% OFF YOUR FIRST ORDER
Read Our Full Brand Review View Lab Report
Smalls is a newer fresh cat food delivery company that allows you to select from an extensive variety of human-grade cat food recipes, then ships them out to you on a monthly delivery schedule. There’s a lot to talk about here, so let’s take a closer look at what Smalls has to offer.
What Kind Of Cat Food Does Smalls Offer?
Smalls offers a staggering array of foods for cats, including fresh, freeze-dried, and kibble recipes. All of their foods are formulated by certified animal nutritionists and meet the AAFCO’s nutritional requirements for all life stages, meaning that they can constitute a complete and balanced diet for kittens, adult cats, and seniors alike.
Their foods are broken into two main categories: Human-Grade Fresh and Freeze-Dried Raw.
The Human-Grade Fresh Lineup Includes:
- Fresh Bird (Chicken)- available in minced or pâté textures
- Fresh Other Bird (Turkey)- available in minced or pâté textures
- Fresh Cow (Beef)- available in minced or pâté textures
Whether minced or blended into a paté, Smalls human-grade foods are fresh, homemade-style products primarily made from tender, flaky muscle meat and organs blended with vegetables. Meat ingredients constitute the bulk of these recipes, making them a species-appropriate choice for your carnivorous kitty.
The Freeze-Dried Raw Lineup Includes:
- Freeze-Dried Raw Bird (Chicken)
- Freeze-Dried Fresh Other Bird (Raw Turkey)
- Freeze-Dried Raw Water Bird (Duck)
Smalls’ freeze-dried formulas are among the meatiest products on the market, containing a mix of muscle meat, organs, and bones, without a lot of additives that your cat doesn’t need.
Instead of being fortified with synthetic vitamins, minerals, and amino acids, the foods rely solely on the nutritional content of raw meat, eggs, goat’s milk, herring oil, and tocopherols.
Unlike other freeze-dried foods that are made with rehydration in mind, Smalls freeze-dried food is served dry. It’s formed into crisp, dry pellets that you pour into a bowl and serve as-is, like kibble.
Be aware that raw food may carry disease-causing bacteria, such as E. coli, that can put cats and their owners at risk of foodborne disease. Talk with your veterinarian if you are considering a raw food diet for your cat.
While Smalls emphasizes their human-grade fresh and freeze-dried raw foods, they also offer kibble as an affordable alternative to their other meal plans. These are more or less your typical grain-free kibble, featuring a fair amount of meat and bound with sweet potatoes and legumes.
They’re a little bit meatier, contain a few more nutraceuticals (food-derived products with extra health benefits), and are slightly lower in carbohydrates than some cheaper dry foods, but they’re still on the plant-heavy side and not nutritionally ideal for cats.
To get a better understanding of what Smalls fresh food looks like, let’s take a closer look at their popular chicken wet cat food recipe.
This recipe is primarily made with cuts of chicken thigh, breast, and liver. These ingredients are the food’s primary source of protein.
Vegetable oil serves as the food’s main fat source, which is disappointing—chicken fat or another animal-derived fat would be more appropriate for your carnivore. In addition to this plant-derived fat, the food contains a smattering of green beans, peas, and kale.
At roughly 6% carbohydrates on a dry matter basis, this food is far from starch-laden and remains a species-appropriate diet that honors your cat’s need as a carnivore.
Ingredients:
Chicken, Chicken liver, Green beans, Peas, Water (sufficient for processing), Chicken hearts, Kale, Tricalcium phosphate, Canola oil, Choline chloride, Potassium chloride, Salt, Taurine, Magnesium Sulfate, Niacinamide, Ferrous sulfate, Zinc sulfate, Vitamin E supplement, Thiamine mononitrate (vitamin B1), Calcium pantothenate (vitamin B5), Copper sulfate, Pyridoxine hydrochloride (vitamin B6), Manganese sulfate, Riboflavin (vitamin B2), Potassium iodide, Folic acid, Biotin (vitamin B7), Vitamin B12 supplement, Vitamin D3 supplement
Guaranteed Analysis
Dry Matter Basis
Caloric Weight Basis
Where And How Is It Made?
All of Smalls’ cat food recipes are made in the USA. Their wet food formulas are manufactured in a USDA-inspected human food processing facility in Chicago, Illinois, while their freeze-dried recipes are made in Green Bay, Wisconsin. Smalls kibble is made in Brainerd, Minnesota.
How Does The Subscription Work?
To sign up for a Smalls cat food delivery subscription, you’ll fill out a questionnaire telling the company about your cat’s weight and dietary preferences, as well as your budget needs.
From there, Smalls will suggest a meal plan that will work for you. With nine meal plans available, you can choose from flexible combinations of dry, freeze-dried, and wet food.
Although Smalls asks you about your cat’s weight, the packets of food aren’t custom-portioned. There’s no real customization here—you’re just choosing a mix of foods that suit your cat’s preferences.
Your first box comes with a selection of starter supplies, including food toppers and flavor additives, plastic containers for food storage, and a guide to help you make the transition from your cat’s former diet.
If you decide to cancel or update your subscription, you’ll find that Smalls is one of the more difficult services to work with. The site can be confusing, the customer portal is limited, and the only way to cancel your subscription—or receive support in general—is by emailing or texting the company. Although Smalls offers attentive customer service, the path to receiving that service is needlessly complex and often frustrating.
How Much Does It Cost?
That depends on which meal plan you choose. Your cheapest option is an all-kibble subscription, which adds up to about $30 per month, while the most expensive box is closer to $130 a month. Compared to other similar cat food delivery services, Smalls food is pretty affordable, with their freeze-dried food being particularly competitively-priced.
It’s also easy to choose a meal plan based on your budget. Instead of dropping the price on you at checkout, the company immediately tells you how much each meal plan will cost, making it an appealing option for those who like to shop by price.
Who Should Try Smalls Cat Food?
With such a broad selection of foods with varied textures, proteins, formats, and flavors, Smalls is a good option for those who want to experiment with their cats’ diet, have a multi-cat home, or need to accommodate a cat with limiting dietary needs.
That said, it’s not the best choice if customization is your top priority.
Although its wide selection makes it a promising option for picky eaters and allows you to get just the right combination of recipes for your feline family, Smalls doesn’t give you portion-controlled meals or foods formulated for your cat’s needs.
What We Liked:
- Outstanding variety of recipe options, including fresh, freeze-dried, and dry food
- Smalls foods are species-appropriate and nutritious
- High-quality, human-grade foods
- Affordable compared to similar services
What We Didn’t Like:
- Not a customized product
- Confusing website, customer experience is hit-or-miss
#2 Best Premium: Raised Right Cat Food Meal Plans Review
Click Here To Save 20% Off Your First Box
Formulated by a team of pet nutrition experts, Raised Right’s recipes are lightly-cooked, human-grade foods primarily made from nourishing animal-derived ingredients. Taking into consideration your cat’s weight, age, and activity level, the foods are shipped out to your house according to a custom delivery schedule.
Traceability and transparency are also part of the Raised Right brand. The Raised Right website allows you to learn more about the origins of every ingredient and releases lab reports for each batch.
What Kind Of Cat Food Does Raised Right Offer?
Raised Right offers two varieties of cat food. One is a turkey recipe and the other is a chicken-based food. Both are formulated for adult cats.
The foods are primarily made from muscle meat and organs, with a smattering of other fresh ingredients. Raised Right foods contain very few synthetic additives. Instead, they rely primarily on the nutrient value of whole foods.
Although they don’t contain the wide range of supplemental ingredients you’ll see in most foods, these recipes are nutritionally complete and balanced according to the AAFCO’s nutrient profiles for maintenance.
To get a better understanding of what Raised Right cat food looks like, let’s take a closer look at their turkey recipe for adult cats.
Raised Right’s turkey recipe for adult cats features a mix of turkey thigh, heart, and liver as its primary ingredients. In addition to these nutrient-rich animal-based ingredients, the food contains an array of fruits, vegetables, and nutraceuticals.
A mix of carrots, blueberries, organic spearmint, cod liver oil, eggshell powder, and a few other ingredients round out the recipe. The food is also supplemented with taurine, ensuring that it meets all of your adult cat’s nutritional requirements.
Overall, this is a protein-rich, relatively high-fat food that doesn’t contain a lot of carbohydrate matter. As a meat-based food, it’s a species-appropriate choice for your carnivorous cat.
Ingredients:
Turkey Thigh, Turkey Heart, Turkey Liver, Carrots, Blueberries, Organic Spearmint, Cod Liver Oil, Egg Shell Powder, Flaxseed Oil, Organic Kelp Powder, Taurine, Thiamine Mononitrate
Guaranteed Analysis
Dry Matter Basis
Caloric Weight Basis
Where And How Is It Made?
Raised Right foods are manufactured in a USDA-certified facility that meets all of the requirements for human food processing. In that facility, human-grade ingredients are cooked to kill pathogens, then lab-tested to ensure that they’re safe to eat.
How Does The Subscription Work?
Raised Right doesn’t give you customized portions, but it does allow you to choose your shipping frequency so that you’ll have just the right amount of food to satisfy your cat’s needs. Their helpful Cat Food Calculator makes it easy to select the shipping frequency.
The website states that “Each box comes with 16 bags. Each bag weighs 1 pound.” Doing the math, each box contains 16 pounds of food.
For example, an active 10-lb cat who needs to maintain its weight would eat 7 ounces of Raised Right each day, so the company would ship out a new package every four weeks. An overweight 15-lb cat with low activity levels who needs to lose weight would need about 6 ounces of food every day, so the company suggests a shipping frequency of one box every 5 weeks.
To set up your Raised Right subscription, you’ll enter information about your cat’s weight, activity level, and weight goals. Based on that information, the company will calculate how many ounces of Raised Right your cat needs per day and provide shipping frequency suggestions to help you divide up your cat’s portions over time.
How Much Does It Cost?
Each 1-pound bag of Raised Right cat food costs $9.99. How that breaks down in terms of daily feeding costs depends on your cat’s weight and calorie needs. For the previous example of the 10-pound active cat, it would cost about $4.50/day to feed Raised Right food.
Compared to other brands, the Raised Right pricing structure is very straightforward and upfront—no guessing how much you’ll pay until you reach the checkout. Full boxes (16 bags) ship free but sample boxes (4 bags) incur a $9.99 shipping fee.
Who Should Try Raised Right?
If transparency and trustworthiness are your priorities, Raised Right looks like a promising option. Their foods are simple, meat-based products that are backed up by industry experts and impressive certifications. This cat food meal delivery service doesn’t have the variety of Smalls, but it looks like a brand you can trust.
What We Liked:
- Formulated by a veterinarian and pet food formulation expert
- Releases documentation on lab testing
- Fully human-grade products
- Species-appropriate recipes honor your cat’s needs as a carnivore
What We Didn’t Like:
- Hasn’t received a lot of customer reviews, making it difficult to gauge customer experience
- Very small selection doesn’t provide a lot of options for picky cats
- The foods aren’t custom-portioned and you’ll still have to measure meals out for your cat
#3 Best Vet-Approved: Just Cats
Click Here To Get 5% Off Your First Order
JustCats is the cat food line associated with Just Food for Dogs, a fresh dog food delivery service. While Just Food for Dogs offers a variety of Pantry Fresh and Fresh Frozen meal options, JustCats has only a single recipe. Their fish & chicken formula is gently cooked in small batches and shipped frozen.
What Kind Of Cat Food Does Just Cats Offer?
JustCats is a fresh cat food delivery service that currently offers only one recipe. This formula is made with 100% human-edible ingredients and gently cooked in small batches to preserve nutrition and flavor. It is formulated by a team of veterinarians and Certified Whole Food Formulation specialists and adheres to AAFCO food nutrient profiles for cats.
To get a better understanding of what JustCats fresh food looks like, let’s take a closer look at their fish and chicken fresh cat food recipe.
The JustCats Fish & Chicken recipe fresh food is made with real, high-quality animal proteins and a proprietary blend of vitamins and minerals. It is a limited ingredient diet that is completely free from fillers and artificial additives, including colors and flavors.
JustCats fresh food is rich in moisture and highly digestible, which makes it a great pick for cats with sensitive stomachs and picky eaters. The only trouble is it contains two common cat food allergens – fish and chicken – so it may not be the best choice for cats with food allergies or sensitivities.
What we love about this formula is that it contains whole-food ingredients. The primary ingredients in this formula are Alaskan Pacific wild-caught cod, whole Atlantic sardines, chicken thighs, chicken hearts, and chicken liver. The only other ingredients are dried yuca root (used to support hydration and to give the product the right consistency) and the vitamin/mineral blend.
Unlike some fresh cat foods, this recipe doesn’t contain any significant carbohydrate additives. In fact, the estimated carbohydrate content is under 5%.
Ingredients
Alaskan Pacific Wild-Caught Cod, Whole Atlantic Sardines, Dried Yuca Root, Chicken Thighs, Chicken Hearts, Chicken Liver, Multi-Vitamin & Mineral Blend.
Guaranteed Analysis
Dry Matter Basis
Caloric Weight Basis
Where And How Is It Made?
JustCats fresh cat food is made in company-owned kitchens located in the United States. Their open-to-the-public kitchens are located in Irvine, CA, and New Castle, DE.
How Does The Subscription Work?
The JustCats subscription works a little differently than other fresh cat food services because there is only one recipe to choose from. You don’t need to fill out a questionnaire. You simply add the desired amount of product to your cart and indicate whether it’s a one-time order or an autoship.
If you choose the autoship option, you get to choose the frequency of your deliveries – every 1 to 8 weeks. If you choose the Autoship option, you’ll save 35% on your first order and 5% on recurring orders.
Something else to keep in mind with JustCats, compared to other fresh cat food delivery services, is that they do not pre-portion the meals or provide custom feeding recommendations. JustCats is only sold in 18-ounce packages, with feeding recommendations made according to body weight.
Fortunately, it’s easy to change or cancel your subscription by logging into your Just Food for Dogs account online. You can also cancel your subscription by contacting customer service directly.
How Much Does It Cost?
JustCats has very simple and straightforward pricing. Each 18-ounce package of fresh food costs $13.95. Keep in mind, however, that shipping may cost extra.
Due to pandemic-related shortages, JustCats has had some inventory issues and no longer seems to be offering free shipping. A flat rate shipping fee of $10 may apply to your order.
In addition to discounts available for autoship orders, local customers can save money by selecting the free local pickup option.
In terms of weekly or monthly pricing, it depends on your cat’s size and calorie needs. A 10-pound cat should be fed around 7 ounces of JustCats fresh food per day, or about 49 ounces per week. That equates to about 2 ¾ packages of cat food, making your weekly cost about $38.
Who Should Try JustCats Cat Food?
Because JustCats uses human-edible ingredients, including premium sources of real animal protein, this food is a great choice for anyone looking to increase the nutritional value and digestibility of their cat’s diet. Any cat can benefit from a high-quality fresh food diet. That said, it may not be the best option for cats with food allergies or sensitivities.
JustCats offers only one recipe and it contains both chicken and fish, two common cat food allergens. It does contain a limited number of ingredients, but if your cat is sensitive to chicken or fish, it may not be the best choice. JustCats may or may not expand its recipe offerings in the future.
What We Liked:
- Rich in real animal protein from chicken and fish
- Gently cooked to preserve nutrition and flavor
- Completely free from fillers and artificial additives
- Save 35% on first autoship and 5% on recurring orders
What We Didn’t Like:
- Only one fresh food formula is currently available
- Some cats may be sensitive/allergic to chicken or fish
#4 Best Alternative: FreshPet Cat Food
Shop For Freshpet On Walmart Shop For Freshpet On Petco
If you like the idea of feeding your cat fresh food but the options above don’t offer the right variety or they’re just too expensive, FreshPet could be a good alternative. FreshPet offers a wide variety of fresh food options from rolls to bite-sized pieces, all available for purchase in your favorite pet stores or online for in-store pickup.
What Kind Of Cat Food Does FreshPet Offer?
FreshPet uses fresh, whole ingredients, including US-raised chicken and beef, to make a variety of fresh pet food products. Everything is steam-cooked to lock in nutrients and processed according to both FDA and USDA standards. Formulas are double-checked by veterinary nutritionists and everything is distributed to major pet store and grocery store brands around the country for easy shopping convenience.
To get a better understanding of what FreshPet cat food looks like, let’s take a closer look at the FreshPet Select Tender Chicken & Beef recipe.
The FreshPet Select Tender Chicken & Beef Recipe comes in a 1-pound bag of bite-sized pieces of fresh, moisture-rich cat food. This grain-free recipe features fresh chicken, chicken liver, and fresh beef as the top three ingredients, with supplemental protein from pea protein, eggs, and ocean whitefish.
As a fresh food, this recipe is rich in the moisture your cat needs for optimal hydration, and the bite-sized pieces are easy to portion and easy to eat. This formula is free from fillers, grains, by-products, and artificial additives. But it does have one thing we don’t like to see in cat food: plant protein concentrate.
Pea protein is one of the top 5 ingredients in this formula, so it could contribute significantly to the overall protein content of the recipe. We also see a few other plant-based ingredients like carrots and spinach, not to mention pea fiber.
Overall, this recipe seems to contain a decent amount of animal-based protein. But it also contains a significant number of plant-based ingredients, which adds up to a higher carbohydrate content than we’d like.
Ingredients:
Chicken, Chicken Liver, Beef, Natural Flavors, Pea Protein, Carrots, Eggs, Spinach, Ocean Whitefish, Pea Fiber, Vinegar, Salt, Potassium Chloride, Beta-Carotene, Taurine,Celery Powder, Choline Chloride, Vitamin E Supplement, Niacin, Thiamine Mononitrate, Calcium Pantothenate, Riboflavin, Pyridoxine Hydrochloride, Biotin, Vitamin B12 Supplement, Vitamin D3 Supplement, Folic Acid, Dicalcium Phosphate, Iron Proteinate, Zinc Proteinate, Manganese Proteinate, Copper Proteinate, Sodium Selenite, Calcium Iodate.
Guaranteed Analysis
Dry Matter Basis
Caloric Weight Basis
Where And How Is It Made?
FreshPet cat food is made in the USA with ingredients sourced from the United States. Their formulas are made in company-owned kitchens located in Bethlehem, PA, and cooked at a low temperature to protect the nutritional integrity of the ingredients.
How Does The Subscription Work?
FreshPet doesn’t sell its products directly through its website, so there is no subscription program. You can find their products in major pet store chains and some grocery stores and discount retailers, so you may be able to set up a recurring order for in-store pickup.
How Much Does It Cost?
Because FreshPet offers a variety of products and they are sold in retail stores not directly through the brand, cost varies greatly. Individual product pricing ranges from around $4.99 for a 1-pound roll to over $30 per bag for some of their complete meals.
If you choose one of FreshPet’s kibble-style foods, your daily cost to feed a 10-pound cat might be between $0.98 and $1.16. If you choose one of their roll-style products, however, you could be paying as much as $4 per day.
Who Should Try FreshPet?
FreshPet offers a wide variety of product types made with different proteins and other flavors. It might be a good option if you’re interested in exploring fresh food for your cat but you’re not ready to make the level of commitment required for a meal delivery service. You can pick up a single bag or roll of FreshPet fresh cat food at your local grocery store or pet store.
The thing to keep in mind with FreshPet is that while the formulation of their formulas is consistent across the board, there may be differences in freshness from one retailer to another. Be sure to check the Best By date on the product before you purchase and store it properly to keep the product fresh.
What We Liked:
- Made with high-quality sources of animal-based protein
- Wide variety of product types and protein options
- Made in the USA with locally sourced ingredients
- Conveniently available in pet stores, groceries, and retail chains
What We Didn’t Like:
- Generally not available for purchase online
- Most recipes contain multiple plant ingredients
- Many products contain carrageenan
The Best Cat Food Meal Delivery Services: In Comparison
| Brand Name | Recipes Available | Delivery Options | How Much It Costs | Key Differences |
| Smalls | Fresh Chicken, Fresh Turkey, Fresh Beef, Freeze-Dried Chicken, Freeze-Dried Turkey, Freeze-Dried Duck, Chicken Kibble, Fish Kibble, Turkey Kibble | Monthly | About $1.00 to $4.30 per day, per cat | Has one of the broadest product selections in this category |
| Just Cats | Fish and Chicken | One-time purchase or regular shipments every 1 to 8 weeks | About $4.64 per day, per cat | Offers only one recipe but has straightforward pricing and high ingredient quality |
| Raised Right | Turkey, Chicken | One-time purchase or regular shipments every 2 to 28 weeks | About $2.433 to $6.71 per day, per cat | Appears to be one of the most authoritative, trustworthy brands in the industry |
| FreshPet | FreshPet Select (varied), FreshPet Vital (varied) | Purchase in-store only | About $0.98 to $4 per day, per cat | Offers a convenient in-store alternative to delivery services for fresh cat food |
In addition to cat food delivery services, you might think about setting up routine deliveries from other retailers.
For example, Chewy offers a subscription service that allows you to set up monthly deliveries of your most-used items. With their Autoship & Save option, you can save 5% on every product in your Autoship order.
With such a wide variety of options available, this alternative gives you the ease of routine home delivery and the ability to give your cat exactly what he wants and needs.
Thank you for reviewing the foods for our feline family members. I was not aware of the Just Foods and Smalls companies..
I would like to try Just Foods for cats but, they are out of stock at this time, so we ordered the trial pack from Smalls.
We previously used NomNom Fish Meals but, unfortunately, they no longer offer the Fish Meals for cats which is why we were searching for another company.
Thanks again for your reviews.
This is a great list, thank you for taking the time to review them and post about the companies in such detail.
I would like to say that Smalls is not consistent. We have been a customer for going on 2 years and for the past year, we have been receiving rotten warm food for our cat. The gently cooked food is frozen, which is the only food we buy. They have offered us a refund several times, yet that does not feed our cat when she runs out of food due to the incompetence of their warehouse. They also have strict shipping days and times and when a new shipment is needing to be sent out to replace the rotten or incorrect product, we’ve been told “we missed the shipping cutoff” for that week. Sometimes that can transpire to another 10 days before cat food is delivered. That is unacceptable in our standards.
They blame a 3rd party shipping company for the problem. I have suggested numerous times a shipping company that without fail always delivers our dog food frozen. I appreciate they are a “newer” company, but the life of my cat has been so disrupted, not to mention the stress and anxiety we experience due not being able to trust our shipments will arrive safe to consume and arrive as the correct order. If this problem only happened once or twice, we could potentially understand. But it has occurred too many times to count. We cancelled our auto-ship and will not recommend them to anyone.
Hi Stacey, thank you for sharing your experience with Smalls. We forwarded your message to the Smalls support team and they said that the issues you experienced may have been related to recent extreme weather in the United States. However, it sounds like your experiences started further back, and I can echo that consistency has been a, well, consistent issue over the last year. Of course, we also have the pandemic to blame for that. At any rate, we’re currently gearing up to do a complete rewrite of this review after ordering new batches of food and re-evaluating their updated customer flow, and I hope to bring good news. Until then, thanks again for being here, and I’m sorry you had a disappointing experience with this company. – Mallory
Im scared of the spearmint in the Raised Right. Many sources claim it is toxic for cats.