Why Declawing Is Bad for Your Cat & What To Do Instead

comments-icon 3 Comments on Why Declawing Is Bad for Your Cat & What To Do Instead
Avatar photo
Fact checked by  Jackie Brown
Share Email Pinterest Linkedin Twitter Facebook

Scratching is, unfortunately, part and parcel of having a cat. It is a natural cat behavior and sometimes your cat might not understand what they can or cannot scratch. When they use their claws on you or your sofa and curtains, it can be challenging to deal with.

Perhaps you’ve heard of declawing and thought it might be the solution. Read on to find out more about what declawing involves, why it is not recommended, and better alternatives to consider.

Key Takeaways

Declawing is the partial amputation of a cat’s toes—a painful procedure that is not recommended.

There are better and more humane alternatives to declawing to help with a cat’s destructive scratching behavior.

Alternatives include providing appropriate scratching surfaces, behavioral modification, and regular nail clipping.

What Is Declawing?

Declawing, also known in veterinary terms as onychectomy, involves the removal of the third toe bone while under general anesthetic. The toe is made up of three bones and the third is the one associated with the claw.

Many people assume declawing involves only removing the claws and do not realize it is a major surgical procedure. It is essentially a partial toe amputation. A veterinarian will carry this out using a scalpel blade, surgical laser, or sterilized guillotine-type nail clippers.

Why Is Declawing Performed?

Elective declawing is requested by pet owners to prevent cats from scratching people and objects, such as furniture. The surgery is usually performed when cats are between 3 and 12 months of age. Most of the time, only the toes on the front limbs are declawed as cats generally don’t cause much damage with their back claws.

Why Is Declawing Not Recommended?

Declawing is a complex and painful surgical procedure. Elective declawing, when done so for human convenience, is an unnecessary mutilation that does not offer any medical benefits to cats. Declawing is illegal in many countries, including the United Kingdom, Australia, and New Zealand. In the United States, the procedure is outlawed in a handful of cities and counties, and completed banned in two states (New York and Maryland).

Complications occur in 50% of cats. These complications include pain, lameness, swelling, infection, and claw regrowth. Research has shown that declawing increases the risk of developing arthritis, back pain, and unwanted behaviors, such as inappropriate urination and defecation, aggression, and biting.

What Are Better Alternatives To Declawing A Cat?

Scratching is a natural feline behavior. It allows cats to mark their territory, leaving their scent as well as visual signals. Scratching also keeps their nails in good condition, through the shedding of the dead outer sheath. Declawing removes their freedom to express an instinctual behavior. Read on to find out more about pain-free alternatives that can be considered.

1. Provide Plenty Of Suitable Scratching Surfaces

You can reduce or eliminate damage to your things by giving your cat a variety of many different scratchers.

If you don’t want your furniture, curtains, and carpets to fall victim to your cat’s claws, then you must provide them with alternative scratching surfaces to fulfill their scratching needs. Scratching posts and pads come in many different forms. The key is to offer variety.

Vertical scratching posts should be of adequate height to allow your cat to stretch out fully on their back legs when scratching. Make sure the base is secure and stable so that the post doesn’t wobble or fall over while being used. Also offer horizontal scratching pads or mats so your cat has more choice.

You can choose scratchers made from various materials, including sisal rope and corrugated cardboard. Experiment with different materials to see what your cat prefers.

Take notice of where your cat has been scratching inappropriately and place a scratching post or pad close to it. It is also a good idea to have a suitable scratching surface positioned near where they usually sleep as cats like to stretch and scratch when they wake up.

2. Attract Your Cat To The Appropriate Scratching Areas

Catnip is a great way to make a new scratching post or pad more attractive to your cat if they are responsive to it. Sprinkle some catnip or use a catnip spray on the top and base. This will encourage your cat to make good use of their appropriate scratching surfaces.

Also consider playing with your cat close to the scratching post. Wand toys are great for this purpose as you can entice them to reach up on to the post with their paws while they are grabbing the toy.

3. Use Positive Reinforcement

Scratching is a natural behavior for your cat and they need to learn what they can or cannot scratch. Though having a cat that scratches furniture can be frustrating, it is important not to resort to punishment for undesirable behaviors. Avoid using water sprays to squirt them and loud noises to deter them, as this can frighten them and damage the bond you have with them.

Instead, positive reinforcement should be used when the correct behaviors are displayed. If you see your cat using the appropriate scratching surfaces that you have provided for them, give them plenty of attention and treats as a reward.

4. Make Unsuitable Scratching Surfaces Less Appealing To Scratch

Deterrent tape can interrupt the scratching behavior long enough for you to redirect it somewhere appropriate.

Before you try this option, ensure you have provided your cat with appropriate scratching alternatives. Cover areas that you don’t want your cat scratching with cling film, double-sided tape, or aluminum foil to make them less attractive. Chairs and sofas can also be covered with plastic sheets or throws and blankets.

5. Provide A Stimulating Environment

Destructive behavior often stems from stress and/or boredom. Ensure your cat has plenty of environmental enrichment that stimulates them mentally and physically. If you have multiple cats, check that you have sufficient food and water bowls, and litter boxes, so that any competition for resources is eliminated.

6. Regular Nail Clipping

Removing the sharp points of your cat’s nails and keeping them short is a good way to prevent injury and damage. This can usually be done every two weeks or so but varies from cat to cat. It is best to get cats used to having their nails clipped from a young age as it makes the procedure much less stressful for everyone involved.

If you do not feel comfortable or confident with cutting your cat’s nails, contact a groomer or your veterinary clinic for help.

7. Use Nail Caps

Nail caps, such as Soft Paws, are soft vinyl covers that are applied over your cat’s nails with adhesive glue. They stay in place for around four to six weeks and fall off when the outer nail sheath is shed. These vinyl nail caps are a better alternative to declawing because cats can still scratch and extend and retract their nails.

8. Seek Help From A Feline Behaviorist

When all else fails, a professional educated in feline behavior can often help.

Perhaps you have tried some of the above options, but your cat is still destroying your furniture with their scratching. If that is the case, consider contacting a feline behaviorist. They will evaluate your cat alongside their home environment and lifestyle, before coming up with a management plan to help you modify your cat’s unwanted behaviors.

Final Words

Hopefully, by this point, you have come to realize that declawing is not the perfect solution for your cat’s scratching behavior. There are many humane and pain-free alternatives that can be considered, as discussed above.

Whenever we try to modify undesirable behaviors, it can take a lot of time and patience. In the case of destructive scratching, this effort is worthwhile if it means avoiding invasive surgery. Your veterinarian can also be a source of help and advice should you need it.

Also Read: Can You Discipline A Cat?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a painless way to declaw cats?

Declawing a cat involves amputation of the last toe joint and removing the third toe bone, under general anesthetic. A veterinarian might use a scalpel blade, surgical laser, or a guillotine-style nail clipper to do this.

No matter which surgical method is used, it is a painful and invasive procedure. Recovery can also take a long time and post-operative complications are common. Declawing can also result in long-term pain.

Why shouldn’t you get your cat declawed?

Putting a cat through a general anesthetic and invasive surgery that is done for human benefit can be considered unethical. It prevents your cat from exhibiting a natural behavior, which is already a welfare concern. The procedure has a high complication rate and has long-term effects such as chronic pain and undesirable behavioral changes.

Is a tendonectomy better than declawing?

Tendonectomy is an alternative surgery to declawing. It involves cutting and removing a small portion of the tendon that allows extension and retraction of the claws. The nails become thickened and continue to grow, so nail clipping is an ongoing requirement.

As with declawing, there are also complications involved with this procedure. It is not routinely recommended. The alternatives listed above should be considered instead, in order to avoid surgery that has no benefit to the cat.

View Sources
Cats.com uses high-quality, credible sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the claims in our articles. This content is regularly reviewed and updated for accuracy. Visit our About Us page to learn about our standards and meet our veterinary review board.
  1. Atkinson, T. (2018). Practical Feline Behaviour. Oxfordshire, UK: CAB International

  2. Fossum, T. (2013). Small Animal Surgery (Fourth Edition). Elsevier Mosby

  3. Martell-Moran, N. K., Solano, M., & Townsend, H. G. G. (2017). Pain and adverse behavior in declawed Cats. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 20(4), 280–288. https://doi.org/10.1177/1098612x17705044

  4. Schwartz, S. H. (2011). Onychectomy & Tendonectomy. Clinician's Brief. Retrieved November 19, 2022

Help us do better! Was this article helpful and relevant?
What can you say about this article?
I am completely satisfied, I found useful information and tips in this article
Article was somewhat helpful, but could be improved
Want to share more?
Thank You for the feedback! We work to make the world a better place for cats, and we're getting better for you.
Avatar photo

About Dr. Beverley Ho BSc(VetSci)(Hons) BVM&S MRCVS

Beverley graduated from the Royal (Dick) School of Veterinary Studies at the University of Edinburgh in 2020. She also has an intercalated honours degree in Literature and Medicine; she achieved this in 2018 and was the first veterinary student to do so. An expert in behavior and nutrition, Beverley currently works as a small animal vet.

3 thoughts on “Why Declawing Is Bad for Your Cat & What To Do Instead”

+ Add Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Christine Swoboda

    Glad to see this article. Have to say the article that you put up previously about declawing cats was extremely disturbing. So having a truthful article about declawing and why it should not be done has redeemed this site as one for cats

  2. tina

    I’ve never had to declaw any of my cats in all of my life. I was at a vet office for some labs on one cat and I witnessed a declaw happening- OMG I couldn’t believe what I was seeing.

    Thanks for promoting no declaw. I have re-covered multiple cat trees and posts myself with free remnants from the carpet installers. I use treats and verbals to reward every time one uses them. Keeping the scratch items near the couch corners and wall corners made the difference. Air Shots keep them off counters and away from new scratching spots if they weren’t using a tree. Once trained, they are reliably avoiding bad habits.
    Jackson Galaxy My Cat From He)) says 10 mins AM and 10 mins PM of play time each day- It works! Once trained, we have play time but it isn’t needed to help with their scratching.